27 Comments
User's avatar
Liz Zimmers's avatar

Heart-stopping and absolutely amazing, a Möbius strip pain and anger and generational grief. LOVED. THIS!

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Thank you, Liz! I feel like I got most of the way there, but might come back to it later. I'm glad you liked it! 🖤

Expand full comment
B Philippe's avatar

Bloody hell, Sean! You are a fantastic writer. This took my breath away, very well done.

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Thank you! 🖤 I appreciate that, B!

Expand full comment
Nico Harlakenden's avatar

“One shall witness and one shall die.”

Like a coin flip echoing in the dark. Chilling.

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

🖤 We all witness and we all die. Fun! haha

Expand full comment
Brittany Kwentua's avatar

Said no, no, no outloud when I got to the end lol awesome story!

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Haha I love that! Thanks for reading! 🖤

Expand full comment
Stephanie Sweeney's avatar

Claustrophobic read! Liked the four flash sections as structure. The end had a gift of the magi echo - decidedly less heartwarming though!

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Yes! Thank you, Stephanie! 🖤

Expand full comment
Shane Bzdok's avatar

Good gawd, man, this was so so good. Excellent in every way. And such a brilliant ending.

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Aww man thank you, Shane! 🖤

Expand full comment
Garen Marie's avatar

Fire as always, my friend! A claustrophobic story that resonates. That dirt like dice—damn!

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Thanks, Garen! I want to hang again soon! :)

Expand full comment
Garen Marie's avatar

For sure!

Expand full comment
Nick Buchheit's avatar

Well done sir! I liked these four a lot. The different perspectives worked really well and filled in the story nicely while driven everything forward. Bravo!

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Thanks, Nick! It was fun to write. Loved trying to use all the prompts.

Expand full comment
typo's avatar

What a story! Loved this. The ending is superb

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Thank you! I’m glad you called that out! I love endings that leave it up to the reader.

Expand full comment
Hanna Delaney's avatar

I read everything you write trying not to look away because I just know it's never going to end well 😂 Fantastic work.

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

😅 I need to shake it up one of these days and have it end well.

Expand full comment
Brock Eldon's avatar

Sean, I think this is one of your best releases The line about the dirt scattering on the coffin lid “like dice” is pitch-perfect (gambling, fate, family into a single sound image), and it makes the later token-flip feel inevitable and planted rather than ornamental. I am almost most struck by the settings and/or atmospheres of your stories: the pine, cigarettes, and the Christmas tree lot anchor the whole thing, even as the perspectives fracture . . . I've read enough of your work now to see that there is a strong and sturdy voice in there across stories. Really enjoyed this one, and I would look forward to one with some more area or period details, for instance. I often imagine your stories through this kind of "vintage filter," and I would be curious to see you anchor stories to a few different decades. (Like the Coen Brothers sometimes do, like Stranger Things did). Just an idea.

Expand full comment
Sandy Shaller's avatar

Sean, I think Liz Zimmers' comments do an excellent job of describing the impact of this story. How many fathers would take a bullet for their son in moment. Getting buried alive is a tough one. I think I would have preferred shooting the guy my son gambled with!!! A painful, thoughtful tale of father/son love.

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

❤️ Thank you, Sandy!

Expand full comment
EJ Trask's avatar

the end was so good! might I say…cosmic???

Expand full comment
Sean Thomas McDonnell's avatar

Yes! Def cosmic! You probably put this in my brain. haha

Expand full comment
🕯️Sister Roberta Lynn🕯️🏴‍☠️'s avatar

Some things just can’t be left alone💛great story

Expand full comment